Friday, February 10, 2006

More on who approached whom

As I've just posted, a story in the the Surrey Leader mentions that rumours concerning the potential defection of the Grewals were circulating in the Indo-Canadian community apparently even before the negotiations of the May 15th-18th, a fact also mentioned in the Ethics Commissioner's report.

One of the conclusions of that report, of course, was that it had been Grewal who had begun the negotiations: he had offered to change parties in exchange for a cabinet post for himself and a senate seat (or diplomatic post) for Nina. While I was stuck on a flight last night I reviewed some of the earlier tapes and noticed something that I hadn't seen before.

As people will remember, each of the tapes and transcripts exists in two versions: a first, heavily edited one that was released to the public on May 31st, and a second one released during the following week that contained a fuller version.

Grewal released transcripts of six of his calls with Sadesh Kalia, a Surrey Liberal who arranged for his meeting with Dosanjh. In the fifth call was the following exchange. Here is a scan of the May 31st transcript:
Grewal tapes

Compare this to the version that Grewal released on June 7th:
GG-SK-call-#5-(June-7th-ed.

Now, the question. Why would someone want to exclude Kalia's words 'You should call him and discuss your proposal'? The reason is quite simple. This innocuous piece of advice makes it clear (again) that it is Grewal who has a proposal to make.

Labels: ,

Surrey Leader: rumours of Grewal's defection preceded meetings

The Surrey Leader is reporting:
Grewal switch rumoured in advance: Dhaliwal

By Dan Ferguson
Staff Reporter
Feb 05 2006

Before the controversy over Gurmant Grewal's secret tapes erupted last May, Sukh Dhaliwal said he heard something was in the works that could displace himself as the Liberal candidate for Newton-North Delta.

"I heard rumours in the community... that Grewal was going to switch to the Liberals," Dhaliwal said Wednesday.

If Grewal, the Tory MP for Newton-North Delta, had crossed the floor to join the Liberal minority government last year, Dhaliwal would have been denied the party nomination because Grewal would become the incumbent Liberal MP for the riding.

Dhaliwal said there was no hint from the Prime Minister's Office that such a change might be coming when he phoned the PMO in Ottawa to ask if there was any substance to the rumours.

"They said no," Dhaliwal said.

Dhaliwal went on to win the party nomination and the subsequent federal election after the controversy-plagued Grewal decided against seeking another term.

Dhaliwal was one of 21 witnesses interviewed by parliament's ethics commissioner during the investigation into Grewal's taping of talks with senior Liberals, whom he accused of illegally offering inducements to switch sides from the Conservatives.

The MP-elect said he was asked if he had any advance knowledge of the Grewal negotiations, and told the commissioner that he had only heard rumours.

Commissioner Bernard Shapiro's report was released last week and concluded that Grewal's surreptitious taping wasn't illegal or a specific violation of MPs' rules of conduct, but the overall effect was to weaken the public's confidence and trust in the integrity of the House of Commons and its members.

Grewal, who claims the initial draft of the report exonerated him, said he is considering legal action over the alleged altering of the findings.

"It's political," Grewal protested. "Ten of the witnesses are well-known Liberals."

Other witnesses interviewed by Shapiro included Gurmant and Nina Grewal, staff members in the Newton-North Delta constituency office, Prime Minister Paul Martin's chief of staff Tim Murphy and prominent Surrey developer Bob Cheema.

According to the findings of the report, Cheema set things in motion on May 14 when he phoned then-Liberal health minister Ujjal Dosanjh to say both Grewals would be willing to join the minority government in return for "a United Nations position or Senate appointment for her and a cabinet post for him."

The commissioner said he was "unable to clarify who, if anyone, encouraged Mr. Cheema to make this approach, and Mr. Cheema himself claimed no knowledge of any such meeting."

Despite Cheema's denial, the commissioner concluded that Dosanjh was "the more credible witness" of the two and the contact did occur as described. Contacted by The Leader on Wednesday, Cheema refused to elaborate. "I got no answer and I don't talk to media," he said.
What do these rumours mean?

One point that probably should be made is that rumours about Dhaliwal's nomination are probably derivative from general rumours about Grewal's defection. According to the Ethics Commissioner's report, there were rumours about the Grewals defecting for a cabinet post and senate seat/UN post already in April. Once the idea of a defection was out there, it would have been a natural conclusion to see that this might affect Dhaliwal. (Indeed, I pointed out in a post of June 3rd that the issue of the Liberal nominations will have been discussed at some point.)

Labels: ,

Friday, February 03, 2006

Surrey Leader: Grewal says ethics report on taping was changed

From a local Surrey paper comes the story that Grewal saw earlier drafts of the Ethics Commissioner's report, that the first draft exonerated him, and that the second and third (final) drafts were changed to find him chiefly at fault and exonerate the Liberals.
Grewal says ethics report on taping was changed

By Dan Ferguson
Staff Reporter
Feb 01 2006

Former Newton-North Delta MP Gurmant Grewal says he received a threatening letter Friday from Parliament’s ethics commissioner after he claimed the commissioner’s report on his taping controversy had been altered to favour the Liberals.

“The letter says if I release the (draft) reports, that would be a violation of the House of Commons Code of Conduct and I would subject to disciplinary action,” Grewal said Tuesday.

“I’ve sent the letter to my lawyer for advice.”

Grewal said he is considering taking legal action over the report, claiming the first draft of the document exonerated him and laid blame at the foot of the Liberals, only to be altered through at least two subsequent versions until it was changed to find him at fault and the Liberals blameless.

He said he was “shocked and disgusted” by the final version of the report by commissioner Bernard Shapiro.

The report condemned Grewal’s decision to secretly tape talks with Liberal health minister Ujjal Dosanjh and Tim Murphy, the prime minister’s chief of staff, on the eve of a crucial May 19 budget vote.

The Conservatives said the recordings implicated the Liberals in an attempt to buy the votes of Grewal and his wife, MP Nina Grewal, just after Tory Belinda Stronach crossed the floor to join the Liberals.

Shapiro said the surreptitious taping was neither illegal nor a specific violation of MPs’ rules of conduct, but said the overall effect was to weaken the public’s confidence and trust in the integrity of the House of Commons and its members.

Shapiro did not review the tapes in making his ruling, something Grewal said turned the investigation into a review of the propriety of taping, not the contents of the tapes.

“It’s about the messenger, not the message.”

Grewal also complained about the witnesses interviewed by the commissioner, saying 10 of the 21 are “well-known Liberals” including his rival for Newton-North Delta, Sukh Dhaliwal.

The Grewal-Dosanjh inquiry report was ready for release on Jan. 20, but was withheld until after the election.

Labels: ,

Thursday, February 02, 2006

The Surrey Now (Jan. 28): Grewal threatens to sue Shapiro

From the Jan. 28th edition of the The Surrey Now
Grewal threatens to sue Shapiro over ethics report

Tom Zytaruk

The fur is flying over Parliament Ethics Commissioner Bernard Shapiro's report on the Dosanjh-Grewal taping affair, with Grewal threatening to sue and Dosanjh accusing Prime Minister-designate Stephen Harper of hiding from the inquiry.

Gurmant Grewal, formerly the Tory MP for Newton-North Delta, cited "serious reservations" with Shapiro's findings while his wife Nina, MP for Fleetwood-Port Kells, dismissed the report as a "sham."

"I might sue the ethics commissioner," Gurmant told the Now. "There might be other lawsuits spilling over from it, I don't know."

This week, Shapiro found Grewal's actions "entirely inappropriate and deserving at the very least, of reproach."

Shapiro also found that former Liberal health minister Ujjal Dosanjh did not offer specific rewards to Gurmant, who secretly taped Dosanjh and the prime minister's chief of staff Tim Murphy. Grewal claimed he was offered inducements to cross the floor and join the Liberals prior to a critical budget vote last May that could have brought the government down.

Shapiro stated in his report that it's not clear whether Grewal actually sought inducements or played the part to entrap Dosanjh, but found his actions "extremely inappropriate" in either case.

"If his intent was the former," Shapiro wrote, Grewal "committed an extremely serious breach" of the Conflict of Interest Code for Members of the House of Commons. "If his intent was the latter," he added, Grewal was then at odds with the MPs' code of conduct.

Grewal said he'd been expecting "good news" after reading the first draft of the report, which he said was "fair." The second, third and final draft, he claims, "significantly changed in context and tone" and he's presently trying to get them released.

Shapiro noted in his report he didn't consider it necessary to rely on the contents of the tapes in reaching his conclusions, "in the face of the wealth of the primary corroborated evidence of all of the witnesses."

Grewal takes issue with this, noting 11 of the 21 witnesses are "known" Liberals, with Sukh Dhaliwal - his Liberal opponent in Newton-North Delta before Grewal dropped out of the race - among them.

Meantime, Dosanjh said he's pleased Shapiro "exonerated" him.

"I think the blame squarely rests at the doorstep of the Conservative Party and Mr. Grewal," he said. Dosanjh noted that Prime Minister Paul Martin testified at the inquiry while Harper, on the other hand, "hid" for four months.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, January 31, 2006

Rules of evidence

I've long considered Andrew Coyne is one of the country's best columnists: at his best, he is intelligent and vigorous, ideologically clear without being unduely partisan. His blog is less impressive--but that is natural enough. The best material is saved for the paying customers--and rightly so. In his recent blog post on the Grewal affair, he's disappointed.

He begins with the report of Ethics Commissioner Shapiro on the Grewal affair, which says this:
Mr. Dosanjh testified that Mr. Grewal was extremely excited about the crossing of the floor of Belinda Stronach, that morning, and how it was now easy for him to be appointed to Cabinet. However, Mr. Grewal’s account was that Mr. Dosanjh suggested a Cabinet position or diplomatic post for him and a Senate seat for his wife...
and then compares this to reports of how the Belinda deal was negotiated.

Before he got to that comparison, however, he should have stopped. There are rules of evidence. One of them is ad fontem--'to the source'. Why rely on Shapiro's report of Grewal's account of his discussion with Dosanjh, when we have a tape of that discussion? The part of the discussion in question--while Dosanjh and Grewal waited for Murphy to join them--is only eight minutes long. Who is right? Grewal, who claimed that Dosanjh offered him a Cabinet seat, a diplomatic post, and a senate seat? Or Dosanjh, who claimed that Grewal claimed that Belinda's defection made appointing him to Cabinet easy? Let's see.

Here is a transcript and translation of the relevant sections. (Again, my thanks to Sohn, Raj, and Mendeep for their help with the Punjabi.) Yellow, as is my regular procedure, marks text that is absent from Grewal's May 31st transcript, but included in the one released June 5th, and red marks places where my text corrects his (please note that the colouring of the text may be incomplete--some minor differences may be unmarked.) The soundfiles have been archived here, where you can download them and double check my work. (The June 5th transcript goes with the June 2nd tape.)
00:00-00:33 -- (Dead Air)
GG (00:33) Hello, how are you? Hello, how are you?
UD Fine, and yourself? Haal Chaal theek hai? Fine, and yourself? You are fine?
GG Haal chaal te theek hai I am fine
UD Pher… So…
GG (00:38) Pher taan theek hai, tuhaanu taan…. So, it is fine. You…
UD I didn’t know that last night I didn’t know that last night
GG Nahin, Nahin.. No, No…
UD Honestly, I did not know … Honestly, I did not know …
GG Achcha? Last night tusi indicate kar rahe si… Is it? Last night you indicated …
UD I said that there are people coming, but I … I'd been told that somebody was, but I did not know who it was. I said that there are people coming, but I … I'd been told that somebody was, but I did not know who it was.
GG Lagda hai… ik-adha hor vee hona hai koi It seems there may be another one or two persons as well)
UD Newfoundland (?) vaale jehre bande hai Those people from Newfoundland
GG untha lai okah ho jaana kanu vote puni or nay puni for them it is going to be difficult to decide who to vote for or not
UD (1:23) chah da cup piyoge? Will you have a cup of tea?
GG Nahin, nahin, Aapaan chheti kariye, tusi jaana honai No, no. Let’s hurry up, probably you have to go…
UD Sure? Tim ne aaune.. Sure? Tim has to come…
GG koi nahin, aa jaande thodi der vich Doesn’t matter, he will come soon
UD Question Period taan do vaje hai ajj Question Period is at 2 o’clock today
GG Achcha, te tiyari nahin karni hundi? OK, but don’t you have to prepare?
UD (unclear) (unclear)
GG Main kiha, shayad note karna painda hovey I thought, maybe you have to make notes…
UD Koi nahin, panj-ku minute lagde hai, car vich hee tiyari kar layee dee hai (Pause) (1:50) I … I think, ihde naal tuhade layee easy ho gaya hai… It’s OK, it takes about 5 minutes, I prepare in the car itself. (Pause) I … I think it [i.e., Stronach's defection] has made the things easier for you…
GG Haan, ih taan hai Yes, that’s true…
UD ihi tusi chahune ho and that’s want you want
GG Ih taan hai. Naale do galaan clear ho gayeeyan hun. Ik taan easy ho gaye, dooja, ih hai ki kal nu kujh ih na kahen ki, baad vich karange kujh. hosakdi hai (2:08) right away, ihde layee. That is true, Moreover, two things have become clear. Firstly, it has become easier. Secondly, they shouldn’t say that they'll do something later. It can happen right away, for her.
UD (2:11) Cabinet right away hosakdi hai Cabinet can be done right away
GG Uh uh Yes
UD (2:15) Cabinet right away hosakdi hai Cabinet can be done right away
GG Uhu, (2:18) right away ho sadki hai, kyonki vacancy kaafi lambe arsey to chali aa rahi hai, want the Parliament to work, (2:21) shortage hai members di Yes, it can be done right away, since the vacancy has been there for a long time, want the Parliament to work, there is shortage of members
UD Actually, you don’t want to lose the advantage. If you do it right away, you lose the advantage of numbers. Those are issues … Actually, you don’t want to lose the advantage. If you do it right away, you lose the advantage of numbers. Those are issues ….
GG Anyway, let’s talk
UD (2:37) I spoke to the Prime Minister and he said he is going to Regina right now, and he will be happy to talk to you over the phone tonight, or in person, if you want to move
GG Theek (‘right’)
UD (3:01) I think you should have a thorough conversation with Tim.
GG OK
UD Because Tim is the Chief of Staff, it is like talking to the Prime Minister.
GG Right
UD Uh jehri right away vali gal hai na, going into cabinet right away is difficult because we don’t want to lose numbers. (3:20) And as far as “right away” is concerned, going into cabinet right away is difficult because we don’t want to lose numbers
GG (pause) I understand, dooje pasiyon, … senate* (NOT CLEAR) vakensiyan vee hagiyan ne kujh… I understand, on the other hand, (in) senate* (NOT CLEAR) there are some vacancies…
UD Ikko hai, B.C. vich There is only one, in B.C.
GG Par hor vee hai ne, bhariyan te nahin saariyan There are more, all have not been filled yet
UD chhe sat six –seven
GG (UNCLEAR) (UNCLEAR)
UD (UNCLEAR) (UNCLEAR)
UD Senate vich tan majority bahut hai There is a big majority in the Senate
GG Haan Yes
GG (3:42) Hun numbering jehri hai uh bahut crucial ho gayee hai kaafi, 151-152 Now numbers have become very crucial, 151-152
UD (3'56) I think, you should, actually, thoda long term naal socho (3'56) I think, you should, actually, think long term
GG Hu, Hu Yes, yes
UD Obviously, you would only do if it is the right thing for you. It is always the right thing for us. Obviously, you would only do if it is the right thing for you. It is always the right thing for us.
GG Haanji, haanji, personally taan… Yes, yes. Personally, ..
UD But you will do the right thing (inaudible). I’ll push as far as I can. At the end I don’t control those things But you will do the right thing (inaudible). I’ll push as far as I can. At the end I don’t control those things
GG Haanji Yes
UD That why it is important for you to meet him, after the Prime Minister. He just now told me that he will be happy to talk to you, after the discussion, if everything is alright. If it appears that there is some understanding. That why it is important for you to meet him, after the Prime Minister. He just now told me that he will be happy to talk to you, after the discussion, if everything is alright. If it appears that there is some understanding.
UD Je na understanding hove ta pher gal karan di lod hee koi nahin If there is no understanding there is no use talking to him
GG Ihde naal, Nina naal ih effect paina hai …. (inaudible) , Saade nal ih effect paina haiki (4'48) ethnic minority de vich…(inaudible) She, Nina, will have the effect that … (inaudible). We will have the effect, that in the (4'48) ethnic minority … (inaudible)
UD That’s right. It is easier for you to use the same kind of language. This is the time to keep the country together, you can’t line up with the Bloc. You go out on a higher principle. In a sense people might say … (NOT CLEAR). That is not such a bad thing for you. Like one of your former leaders. She was a leader in your party and she is a senior leader.
GG She was a leadership candidate, yes.
UD She was one of the leaders in the party
UD Vaise taa, it is not an easy thing. I wouldn’t. You really have to think. Main aap sochda haan, Waheguru karega taa it might be possible. Nobody will make you totally blunt promise. That is not done is politics usually. (NOT CLEAR). You might be better off for yourself, about asking all you are looking for is for your wife rather than for you, because you will have a pension or something, you can go right away… You can ask for both, but that might be the only thing that might be feasible. I haven’t talked to them, that’s just my way of thinking. Main tuhade naal gal kar riha haan, tusi kidaan karna hai vekh lao. I think you should tell Tim what you have in mind. Edaan nahin kadey vee hunda ki mainu aah cheez chahidi hai taan karoon. Then that’s not good for you. I know that you might not be ready to do it right now you certainly be looking for a significant appointment for her, not for you. How old are you now? In fact, it is not an easy thing. I wouldn’t. You really have to think. My own thinking is that, if the God wishes, it might be possible. Nobody will make you totally blunt promise. That is not done is politics usually. (NOT CLEAR). You might be better off for yourself, about asking all you are looking for is for your wife rather than for you, because you will have a pension or something, you can go right away… You can ask for both, but that might be the only thing that might be feasible. I haven’t talked to them, that’s just my way of thinking. I am just telling you, you decide what to do. I think you should tell Tim what you have in mind. It never works like this that you give me such and such thing and I’ll do it. Then that’s not good for you. I know that you might not be ready to do it right now you certainly be looking for a significant appointment for her, not for you. How old are you now?
AA 47 47
BB te tuhadi pension? And your pension?
AA Athth saalan ‘ch In 8 years
BB Athth saalan lai? For 8 years?
AA Athth saalan tak… 55 lug jange After 8 years… I will be 55.
There is nowhere in the above exchange where (as Grewal stated) "Mr. Dosanjh suggested a Cabinet position or diplomatic post for [Grewal] and a Senate seat for his wife".

The point? Coyne compares two negotiations. He knows next to nothing about either. But he could know more about the one, if he wanted to.

Labels: ,

Sunday, January 29, 2006

weird problem with an old interview of Nina

While going through Ethics Commissioner Shapiro's reports I noticed something odd. Consider this:
Mr. Grewal and Mrs. Grewal both testified that while on their way to Question Period on Monday, May 16, 2005, he informed her for the first time that he had been contacted by Mr. Kalia. Mrs. Grewal’s response was “you’re wasting your time since, you know, we’re not going to be joining the Liberals.”
When did they give this testimony? During the period July 18-22, when Shapiro was in Vancouver. Within a few days of this, Nina gave an interview with the Now newspaper (here, archived here.) The story resulting from was published Monday, July 25:
Both MPs appeared Thursday before ethics commissioner Dr. Bernard Shapiro in New Westminster to testify about the tape recordings.

In an exclusive interview at her constituency office Thursday, Nina Grewal complained of media bias and Liberal spin-doctoring.
So she was interviewed by the Now the same day as she had appeared before Shapiro: Thursday, July 21st.

In the Now story about her interview, one finds this:
The couple is unique in Canadian political history in that they are married MPs representing side-by-side ridings. She realizes she's a "pioneer," still, she wants people to know she's her own woman and resents being treated like Gurnina.

Grewal said she wasn't at the meetings between her husband and the Liberals and had nothing to do with the tapes.

"I didn't participate in the conversations," she said. "I wasn't there at all." In fact, she added, she was in Ottawa at a training session when Gurmant met the Liberals in Vancouver.
This is clearly wrong. The meetings with Dosanjh and Murphy took place in the parliamentary offices of Dosanjh and Grewal, respectively.

When I read this the first time last summer, I had assumed that somehow this had gotten mixed up and that she was in Vancouver and he was in Ottawa (see my comments here, obviously wrong since Nina asked a question during question period: here).

But look at what she had said to Shapiro only a few hours before being interviewed by the Now. She told Shapiro that Gurmant and she, both in Ottawa, had discussed the possible defection to the Liberals; what can only be a few hours later she told the Now that they could not have discussed it because they were in different cities.

There may be a perfectly innocent explanation for the confusion: remembrances about specific times and places can grow dim over time. But to have different recollections within a few hours? She could be lying in one case or the other. But for what possible gain? It's baffling.

Labels: ,

Saturday, January 28, 2006

Ethics Commissioner's report seriously flawed (1): he doesn't answer the question asked

At this evening's Blogger meet-up, I met Andrew Coyne, who mentioned that he has a column coming out tomorrow in which he will slam Ethics Commissioner Shapiro's report. Knowing this blog's work, he said that he assumed that I had a different opinion.

We didn't get a chance to explore this any further, but I think Coyne would be surprised to hear that I have at least two serious problems with what Shapiro has done.

First, let us consider the allegation that he was set
(i) Mr. Grewal sought inducements from Minister Dosanjh or that Minister Dosanjh offered inducements to Mr. Grewal to change his vote on matters before the House of Commons of Canada. (emphasis added)
It seems to me that Shapiro has ignored an important phrase here.

There is nothing in the tapes that suggests that Grewal sought an inducement to change his vote. What Grewal wanted was to change his party, and he hoped to score a senate seat for Nina and a cabinet post for himself in the process. The prospect of Grewal's abstention from the confidence motion of May 19 was brought in only at the end of the negotiations. (For a brief overview of how I interpret the course of the courtship, see here.) More importantly from the point of view of this inquiry, the quesiton of abstention was raised by Murphy, and (as I read the transcripts) never seriously entertained by Grewal.

Grewal was not trying to sell a vote, but his over-all political allegiance. He would become a Liberal if they gave him x and y. Now, in so far as Shapiro has identified Grewal as the initiator of the negotiations and the one who had asked for (rather than being offered) a cabinet, diplomatic post, and/or senate seat, he's been correct. And in so far as he's cleared Dosanjh of having offered any of these things, he's correct.

But by having misidentified the goal of negotiations he misunderstands the affair and finds Grewal guilty of something that he didn't quite do. Although I am no friend of Grewal, that's not right.

(I'll discuss my second problem with Shapiro's in a subsequent report.)

Labels: ,

Thursday, January 26, 2006

New in Ethics report (6): Grewal's negotiations did not start out as a 'sting'

From the Ethics Commissioner's report:
Mr. Grewal and Mrs. Grewal both testified that while on their way to Question Period on Monday, May 16, 2005, he informed her for the first time that he had been contacted by Mr. Kalia. Mrs. Grewal’s response was “you’re wasting your time since, you know, we’re not going to be joining the Liberals.”
Grewal has claimed on many occasions that he never intended to become a Liberal and that he was stringing the Liberals along in order to expose them. (The Ethics Commissioner condemns such an attempt at entrapment as a breach of the code.) What both Grewals told the commissioner here shows that to be false. Nina's assertion that Gurmant's negotiations were a 'waste of time' because they were not going to become Liberals strongly suggest that crossing the floor was presented to her as a realistic possibility. Nina was skeptical, or opposed, or some combination of the two.

This helps us nail down the question of when Grewal decided to turn his attempt to cross the floor into a sting. Apparently on his way to question period on May 16th, he still thought crossing the floor was a possibility. The fact that there is no tape of the pizza date on the evening of the 16th may be relevant.

[edited for clarity]

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 25, 2006

New in Ethics report (2): Nina knew about the discussions

From the Ethics Commissioner's report:
Mr. Grewal and Mrs. Grewal both testified that while on their way to Question Period on Monday, May 16, 2005, he informed her for the first time that he had been contacted by Mr. Kalia. Mrs. Grewal’s response was “you’re wasting your time since, you know, we’re not going to be joining the Liberals.”
This will have been before the 'pizza date' later that evening, which was the first time Dosanjh and Grewal discussed the matter directly.

This helps clarify something that's been unclear for quite some time: the question of when Nina was informed about the negotiations. Up to this point, Nina has said little about them except that she was involved. Indeed, the Toronto Star (story archived here) reports that, when asked about the negotiations last June, she said:
"nobody approached me, I wasn't part of any negotiations."

Labels: ,

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

This is bizarre

See this story about Conservative Candidate in Malton, John Sprovieri in 24 Hours Vancouver. It seems he borrowed Nina Grewal's issue page, including a statement
"Gurmant (Grewal) and I are two separate MPs representing different ridings. Gurmant not running in this election affects me personally, but not professionally."
Someone in Sprovieri's campaign room has quickly taken down the page (here). But you can see the old one in google cache here.

Update Even better are Mr. Sprovieri's thoughts on abortion:
"If you want to know my opinion, I am a woman, end of discussion."
Here's a screen capture:
Sprovieri.gif



Update 2. Sprovieri is now getting in a slanging match with his Liberal rival over one another's competence in English: here

Labels: ,

Sunday, December 18, 2005

Nina in the tapes (8): Nina might not win as a Liberal

As we've seen, Nina came up quite a bit in Grewal's discussions with the Liberals about changing parties. Grewal asked for a senate seat for her, as we saw, but was refused. One of the reasons that Grewal was so keen to get her such an appointment had to do with the electoral realities of her riding.

Grewal begins by praising the way that Harper had stood up for him during the Immigrant-bonding scheme and asserting that he had a bright future if he stuck with the Conservatives. Grewal wouldn't cross without an equivalent offer. At this point, the subject changes to Nina.
Nina-wont-win-TM-UD-GG-p.-1.gif
Dosanjh points out that Nina's chances of election were not good as a Liberal. Grewal agrees. It would be easier for him as a Liberal, tougher for her.

Labels: ,

Saturday, December 17, 2005

Nina Grewal can stand on her head!

The Globe and Mail has a profile of Nina that Grewal watchers will no doubt be interested in. On the whole she is portrayed positively. Nina asserts her independence from Gurmant--though one could hardly imagine her doing otherwise.

There are, of course, some surprises here. Apparently Nina can stand on her head! And she makes the rather odd promise to smack her opponents if they bring up Gurmant's antics (which she again denies knowing anything about). And even odder her saying there have been times when she's wanted to smack Gurmant himself.

Stranger and stranger. Anyway, here you go:
Grewal ready to run on her own

By GARY MASON
Saturday, December 17, 2005 Page A12

SURREY, B.C. -- It's Nina Grewal, like you've never seen her before. "I was quite a good athlete in school," says Ms. Grewal, sitting behind a large mahogany desk in her Surrey constituency office. "I played all sports. I could do cartwheels, handstands, you name it. Would you like to see?" Are you kidding? Of course I would. Ms. Grewal gets up, finds an open bit of carpet and, within seconds, is standing on her head. And talking at the same time.

"Is this a good handstand?" asks Ms. Grewal, the Conservative MP who is seeking re-election in the riding of Fleetwood-Port Kells. "What do you think, Gary? Can you believe this?" Ah, frankly, no. Nor can I believe the woman I've just spent an hour talking to is the same one constantly depicted in the media as the mindless, deferring puppet of her man, Gurmant, the other half of the first husband-and-wife team to sit in the House of Commons simultaneously.

Gurmant, of course, is the one who got caught up in a bizarre taping scandal last year, which ended up hurting him far more than the Liberals he said he was trying to entrap. When the tapes were later ruled to have been altered, it was Mr. Grewal who took the fall.

When he announced that he was not seeking re-election as the Conservative MP for Newton-North Delta because he didn't want to be a distraction to his party, it left many to wonder -- how would Nina survive in Ottawa without him?

"I will be just fine," she says, leaning forward on her desk. "It is too bad what happened to Gurmant. But as you know, whistle-blowers are always punished, never rewarded. So my husband had to pay the price because he blew the whistle and it's not easy blowing the whistle on the government."

For the record, Ms. Grewal says she didn't know her husband was going to tape conversations with a key Liberal strategist as well as Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh. When Gurmant later told Nina he had evidence of the Liberals trying to entice the couple with plum posts if they crossed the floor, she thought it would be bad news for the government.

Ms. Grewal is well aware that her opponents will try to use the taping scandal against her in this campaign. Particularly Liberal candidate Brenda Locke, a former B.C. cabinet minister, who has a lead over Ms. Grewal, according to recent polling. So, what will Nina do when Ms. Locke raises the matter?

"If she's going to bring it up she's going to be smacked," Ms. Grewal says. "She's going to be smacked. She's going to be smacked and well, I've got all sorts of things on her from her time in government [provincially] and I'll bring that up."

Smacked? Smacked? Well, we'll all want to be there for that.

There's little doubt Ms. Grewal would rather she not have this issue to deal with in a race as close as hers. There have been many times, I'm sure, when she's wanted to "smack" her husband for coming up with such a stupid idea in the first place.

"Of course there have been times," she says. "Of course. But what's gone is gone, Gary. Let's look at the future. You can't keep repenting what's happened in the past."

If my interview with Ms. Grewal is any indication, it would appear she is determined to remake the image many have of her as the dutiful wife who rarely utters a word unless it is first stamped for approval by her husband. As well, she intends to correct the perception that she's been a useless MP who never has a thing to say in the House.

"First," she says, "people have various ideas that Gurmant always walks in front of me, issuing this instruction to me and that instruction. They don't know that I'm my own person, my own independent person with my own independent thoughts, views and responsibilities. I don't want to be overshadowed by my husband. I'm not a person like that.

"And I also want you to know that in the one and a half years I was in Parliament I'm very proud of my record. Go to http://www.howdtheyvote.ca, and you'll see they rank the MPs based on how much they said and did in the House of Commons. I'm really proud to say that I'm ranked 114 out of 308 MPs. And I've spoken more than 25 cabinet ministers."

As is the case in most ridings, the campaign in Fleetwood-Port Kells is not yet in full swing. After Christmas is when you can expect tight races like this one to take on a different hue and tone. Given the potential material Liberals have to work with, things could get a little nasty.

When her husband decided not to run again, Ms. Grewal said she was sad, but not for a second did she consider not running herself. "Why should I?" she says. "Gurmant was an MP for a long time before I ran for politics. He was away in Ottawa while I was home. Now he can do what I was doing for awhile. I'm Nina Grewal. I'm my own person."

And one who will stand on her head for constituents.
Other notable news stories about Nina can be found here and here

Labels: ,

Thursday, December 15, 2005

Nina in the tapes (7)

Grewal's negotiations with the Liberals were not going well. He had asked for a senate seat and was told no. He hinted at a cabinet post; the Liberals did not bite, hoping that he would cross anyway.
ethnic-woman-TM-UD-GG-p.-14.gif
Grewal now restates his value to his own party. He and Nina were the Tory's only ethnics in BC--and Nina the only minority woman. Also, Grewal feels loyalty to Harper.

Labels: ,

Nina in the tapes (6): a senate seat sought for Nina

One of the worst moments in the tapes for the Conservatives comes on p. 13 of the June 5th transcript. After complaining bitterly about his tangles with Joe Volpe over the last election and Grewal's visa bond scheme, and Murphy suggests that an apology from Volpe might be arranged, Grewal makes his moves:
senate-for-Nina-(TM-UD-GG-p.gif
This part of the transcript is especially problematic for the Conservative version of events. First, it clearly shows that Grewal was asking for an appointment, not being offered one (as he had claimed here, §[3], for example). Second, it clearly shows that Nina was at the center of the discussions, which is difficult to square with her claim that she knew nothing of the negotiations.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, December 13, 2005

Nina in the tapes (5)

Once Tim Murphy arrived, he, Grewal, and Dosanjh discussed the general political situation, the way that the independents might vote in the coming parliament, and the potential impact of the defection: Grewal remarks that the effect will be felt around the world. (It's unsurprisingly, really, that all this was edited out of May 31st tapes: Grewal's vanity makes one cringe, here.)
Have-you-spoken-to-your-wif.gif
Dosanjh again is the one to bring up Nina. He asks Gurmant whether they'd spoken and whether he is speaking on behalf of both. Grewal affirms that he is.

Labels: ,

Monday, December 12, 2005

Nina in the tapes (4)

Continuing our review of places in the tapes where Nina appears (begun here and here). When we last saw our favorite ex-MP, he had confirmed that he had spoken to Nina, and that he and Nina would not cross unless they got 'something good quickly' here). After commenting again on the closeness of the coming votes in the House of Commons, Dosanjh gives Grewal some advice. Here is the May 31st transcript:
Only ask for Nina.gif
Here is the June 5th transcript (yellow marks what is new there):
Nina in tapes #2.gif
Here is my version (red marks what was left out of both Conservative transcripts):
UD Vaise taa, it is not an easy thing. I wouldn’t. You really have to think. Main aap sochda haan, Waheguru karega taa it might be possible. Nobody will make you totally blunt promise. That is not done is politics usually. (NOT CLEAR). You might be better off for yourself, about asking all you are looking for is for your wife rather than for you, because you will have a pension or something, you can go right away… You can ask for both, but that might be the only thing that might be feasible. I haven’t talked to them, that’s just my way of thinking. Main tuhade naal gal kar riha haan, tusi kidaan karna hai vekh lao. I think you should tell Tim what you have in mind. Edaan nahin kadey vee hunda ki mainu aah cheez chahidi hai taan karoon. Then that’s not good for you. I know that you might not be ready to do it right now you certainly be looking for a significant appointment for her, not for you. How old are you now? In fact, it is not an easy thing. I wouldn’t. You really have to think. My own thinking is that, if the God wishes, it might be possible. Nobody will make you totally blunt promise. That is not done is politics usually. (NOT CLEAR). You might be better off for yourself, about asking all you are looking for is for your wife rather than for you, because you will have a pension or something, you can go right away… You can ask for both, but that might be the only thing that might be feasible. I haven’t talked to them, that’s just my way of thinking. I am just telling you, you decide what to do. I think you should tell Tim what you have in mind. It never works like this that you give me such and such thing and I’ll do it. Then that’s not good for you. I know that you might not be ready to do it right now you certainly be looking for a significant appointment for her, not for you. How old are you now?
AA 47 47
BB te tuhadi pension? And your pension?
AA Athth saalan ‘ch In 8 years
BB Athth saalan lai? For 8 years?
AA Athth saalan tak… 55 lug jange After 8 years… I will be 55.
What are the differences?

What is in the June 5th transcript but not in the May 31st one is in yellow: that Dosanjh told Grewal that he would not be likely to get anything for himself, and he might have a better chance of making a pitch for Nina.

What is in red has also been excluded from the June 5th translation/transcript, but is audible (according to my Punjabi-speaking helpers) in the tapes. It is being made public here for the first time. Dosanjh here clearly tells Grewal that there will be no clear x-for-y deal. That was not what Grewal had told the public and it was therefore cut.

Labels: ,

Saturday, December 10, 2005

Nina in the tapes (3)

For those coming late, I've been reviewing the role of Nina Grewal in the Grewal affair. For the first two places where she appeared in the tapes, see here and here.

The third reference to Nina comes soon after the second. Dosanjh asks Gurmant point blank whether he'd consulted Nina about the proposed defection. Here is the conversation from the June 5 transcript (yellow, again, marks sections that someone had edited out of the May 31st tape):
Talk-to-Nina-.gif
Certain snippets have been left out of the translation, again, however. Here is what my Punjabi friends have helped me reconstruct (yellow, as above, is what was snipped out of the May 31st tapes ; red, what can be heard in the June tapes but is not in the June transcript):
UD (5'33) tusi Nina naal gal kIti hai (5'33) Have you talked to Nina?
GG haanji, dovein decided ta nahin haan, dwindling jihe haan. Depend karde, ki milda ki hai. Je ta quick changa haiga taa tahra tarhi ho jaye, je zyada hee ho jaaye taa baad vich haali karaange. Yes. Both of us are not decided, we are kind of dwindling. It depends on what we get. If we get something good quickly, then it can be done right away. But if it is too much (of waiting) then we’ll do it later.
UD It is difficult. You know the situation. Ais haalat vich kujh nahin ho sakda. Cabinet is quick It is difficult. You know the situation. Nothing can be done in the present circumstances. Cabinet is quick
GG kithe vi ho jaaye je halaan …(NOT CLEAR ) vich jagah naa hove. May be any other place, if at present there is no place in …. (NOT CLEAR)
UD You lose numbers. You lose numbers You lose numbers. You lose numbers
GG Number taa tuhanu immediately mil jaane, … te ik ne Senate vich jaane You will get numbers immediately. … And one has to go to Senate.
UD Agle chhe mahine taa number nahin rehne. Jehrha banda chalaa jayega… There won’t be numbers for the next six months. The person who goes …
GG Haan, haan, I understand Yes, yes I understand
Grewal here refers to the decision to change parties as a mutual one: whether he and Nina will go ahead with the defection depends on "what we get, if we get something good, then it can be done right away".

There is no surprise that this was cut out of the tapes--it's highly embarassing to the Grewals and disproves their claim to have been the pursued, rather than the pursuers, in this relationship. What is a bit of a surprise is that this the transcript of June 5th left out of its text these words that can be heard on the tapes.

(By the way, if any Punjabi speakers want to download the recordings and improve the text and translations to the Punjabi sections of the transcript, you can download the recordings here)

Labels: ,

Grewal interviewed by Hindustan Times

Grewal has spent much of the last months avoiding the press. In the last week he has granted an interview to the Hindustan Times (see here). Here it is:
An Indian drama in Canada polls

CANADA DIARY | Gurmukh Singh

December 4, 2005

Much should be read (or not) into the decision of the Indo-Canadian MP Gurmant Grewal not to seek re-election to the House of Commons this time around. The minority Liberal party government, led by Paul Martin, fell last week, necessitating a fresh general election. Grewal represents the Newton-North Delta riding (constituency) in the Canadian Parliament.

The young Indo-Canadian made headlines this summer when he recorded his conversation with Canadian Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh, a fellow Indo-Canadian, when he approached Grewal allegedly with the offer of 'rewards' if he jumped to the Liberal party or voted for the Liberal party to save the government from falling during the no-confidence motion.

Grewal also taped his conversation for Prime Minister Paul Martin's chief of staff Tim Murphy and went public with them, saying that the Liberal party tried to bribe him and his wife Nina Grewal, who represents another riding, just before the vote.

After the government survived because of the speaker's vote, the tape issue led to political mudslinging.

Ujjal and Murphy said they never made any offer to Grewal, and that the tapes released to the media were selective and doctored.

The issue was referred to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, and now is pending before the Ethics Commission.

In the wake of the tape scandal, the media went tong and hammers after Grewal as he was already involved in another issue impinging on his integrity. It related to his seeking guarantee of thousands of dollars from those who sought the MP's help in securing visiting visas for their relatives. Grewal said he wanted this to ensure that the visitors didn't stay back in Canada.

Now when the house has fallen and the tape scandal is still fresh, Grewal says he has decided not to seek re-election for the simple reason that he doesn't want the Opposition to use this issue in the election. He spoke with this correspondent about his future course of action.

Excerpts:

Doesn't your decision to pull out of the fray amount to capitulation to the Liberal party onslaught against you?

No, it is not. I have served the House thrice for nine years and am proud of what I have accomplished. Now that they - the Liberal party and the national media - are resorting to dirty tactics, I have decided not to let them take further advantage of the issue. I am clean and I am all for accountability in public life. It is dirty politics by the Liberals who will go to any lengths to save their government. People have seen their real face before the last no-trust motion - how they lured Opposition MPs.

It is said that you and your party were selective in releasing the tapes and that they were doctored?

It is all part of their propaganda. When I blew the whistle in May, they made all these accusations. They referred the issue to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP). I came out clean. And then with an eye on the election, they referred the matter to the Ethics Commission (come to think of it, the RCMP has a higher profile than the Ethic Commission). Now that that report is going to be critical of the Liberal party they have not tabled it in the house.

[buckets notes: it was not the Liberals who referred the matter to the RCMP and the Ethics Commissioner, but the NDP and Bloc.]
Don't you think you could have fought them more effectively by staying in the fray?

I don't want my leadership to be distracted by the Liberal propaganda. I made the decision in the larger interest of the party and conveyed this to my leader Stephen Harper. He appreciated my views and allowed me to take this step. The Conservastive party will form government this time.

So you could be rewarded later for your sacrifice?

No, I am not after any office. I was offered cabinet position thrice but I refused. I have never made deals in my life. Let me emphasise that whatever I set out to do in life, I did very well in that field. Before leaving India, I did my MBA and was a very successful executive with a multinational in the early 1980s (!). In Liberia where I moved after marrying Nina, I was a successful businessman and university professor. Then I came here in the early 90s and became an MP within just six years. When my wife became an MP this year, we became the first MP couple in Canada!

In the House of Commons, I have the record of speaking more than any of the 308 MPs. Till now; I have introduced 45 bills and motions. Out of these, two have passed. One has become a law of this land. Which is a record in Canadian parliamentary history - that an Opposition MP's bill became law. And mind you, it was a substantial bill in the sense that it was a regulatory bill.

For my record and perfect attendance in the house, they gave me the award of 'Iron man.'

Furthermore, I was the first to raise in Parliament the issue of recognition of foreign degrees in Canada. Then, in 1999, I introduced the whistle-blower bill for protection to those who expose wrongdoings in public life.

Even my opponent will tell you that I repeatedly raised the issue of apology from the government for the Komagata Maru episode. It was I didn't care about Canada's sanctions on India after N-blasts in May 1998 and went to Delhi to meet Indian leaders. I fought for lifting of those sanctions. I exposed corruption in the Canadian missions in New Delhi and Islamabad, raised the issue of recognition for the five Sikh - five Ks -- symbols, and the discrimination against seniors from Asia who are eligible for pension only 10-year stay in Canada while those coming from Europe are eligible for it straightway.

Will you campaign for your wife?

Yes. I will go out to people and explain my decision. Nina is on a solid ground.

Labels: ,

Thursday, December 08, 2005

Nina in the tapes (2)

Nina Grewal (Conservative candidate in Fleetwood-Port Kells) was mentioned several times in the Grewal tapes, which is natural enough given that Gurmant and the Liberals were discussing the defection of both Grewals. The first was when Sadesh Kalia makes clear to Gurmant that both Nina and he are invited to discuss changing parties with Ujjal Dosanjh over pizza. (For the call, see here).

The second moment is a little difficult to untangle. Here is how the Conservative transcript that was released on June 5 records the conversation (yellow, again, marks what they had edited out of the tapes released May 31st):
Nina-is-ethnic-&-a-woman.gif
Next is the same text, with the Punjabi running parallel. (Again, my thanks to Sohn, Raj, and Duldip for their help with the Punjabi text.) Yellow (as before) marks what was excised from the May 31st tape; red marks corrections to the Conservatives final, June 5th, transcript)
UD Obviously, you would only do if it is the right thing for you. It is always the right thing for us. Obviously, you would only do if it is the right thing for you. It is always the right thing for us.

GG
Haanji, haanji, personally taan…
Yes, yes. Personally, ..
UD
But you will do the right thing (inaudible). I’ll push as far as I can. At the end I don’t control those things
But you will do the right thing (inaudible). I’ll push as far as I can. At the end I don’t control those things
GG
Haanji
Yes
UD
That why it is important for you to meet him, after the Prime Minister. He just now told me that he will be happy to talk to you, after the discussion, if everything is alright. If it appears that there is some understanding. Je na understanding hove ta pher gal karan di lod hee koi nahin
That why it is important for you to meet him, after the Prime Minister. He just now told me that he will be happy to talk to you, after the discussion, if everything is alright. If it appears that there is some understanding. If there is no understanding there is no use talking to him
GG
Ihde naal, Nina naal ih effect paina hai …., Saade nal ih effect paina haiki (4'48) (inaudible) leadership candidate (inaudible) ethnic minority de vich…(inaudible)
She, Nina, will have the effect that … We will have the effect, that in the (4'48) (inaudible) leadership candidate (inaudible) ethnic minority de vich…(inaudible)
Two things were cut, here. First, Dosanjh's statement that there was no point in Grewal meeting with the Prime Minister unless an understanding had been reached. This was cut (one can only assume) because it was not consistent with Grewal's claim that he'd been offered a Cabinet post and a senate seat. The other deletion was to Nina. But even the corrected transcript that the Conservatives released on June 5th disguise the fact that this passage was about Nina, disguising her name behind the mysterious reference "inaudible (Punjabi name)".

(The text is still highly deficient, and if any other Punjabi speakers out there want to download the recording (here) and see if they can improve the text they are welcome to.)

Why was Nina's name edited out of the recordings in the first place and disguised behind "inaudible Punjabi name" in the Conservative's corrected version. To ask the question is to answer it. Despite the highly fragmentary nature of the text, Grewal is clearly arguing that he and Nina are valuable acquisitions for the Liberal 'stable' because they are both 'ethnics' and Nina is a woman. The fact that he has to work so hard to sell himself and his wife undermined the central pillar of his story--that the Liberals had approached him rather than vice versa.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, December 07, 2005

Is Grewal planning to use Nina for a come-back?

Vanouverite Ken Gardiner raises some interesting questions about Grewal's recent decision to leave politics (here)
I don’t think Gurmant Grewal will be out of the game for long. His MP wife Nina is the ace up his sleeve and it’s time to reshuffle the deck. I predict that he will use Nina to continue networking while he plans a quick comeback.
As Mr. Gardiner points out, the idea that there is much political separation between the two is difficult to sustain: he is known to have coached her politically and (as we'll be exploring over the next few days) felt comfortable negotiating on her behalf.

Labels: ,